Showing posts with label Reading Response. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Reading Response. Show all posts

Monday, May 19, 2014

Romeo and Juliet - Who is to Blame?

Jane Zeman 811
Romeo and Juliet essay

The events that take place in the play, Romeo and Juliet, all lead up to the tragic ending consisting of multiple deaths, including the deaths of Romeo and Juliet. The character that is  mainly responsible for these deaths is Friar Lawrence. After Romeo and Juliet fall in love, Romeo goes to the Friar to marry them and the Friar says yes. The Friar know that this is not socially acceptable as Romeo’s family (the Montagues) and Juliet’s (the Capulets) have a long-standing grudge. If Friar Lawrence had stepped in and ended Romeo and Juliet’s relationship, lives would have been spared.
When Romeo came to the Friar and asked him to marry them the Friar did it because he thought the marriage of Romeo and Juliet would help resolve the grudge between the two groups. The Friar’s intentions were good, in the play it says, “…For this alliance may so happy prove To turn your households’ rancor to pure love.” This quote means that he would marry them if only to end the grudge between the two families. However, by doing so, he put Romeo and Juliet in a bad position with their parents. In the text it says, “Is Roseline,that thou dist love so dear, So soon forsaken? Young men’s love then lies Not truly in their hearts, but in their eyes.” This quote shows that Friar Lawrence doesn't believe that Romeo is acting rationally or responsibly in terms of his desire to get married to Juliet. The Friar should have prevented Romeo from marrying Juliet because he knew that he was not using the best judgement and also because the Friar understood the consequences of marrying them.
After Romeo was exiled for killing Tybalt, a Capulet, Friar Lawrence helped Juliet fake her death so that Romeo could meet her in the cemetery. A number of things could have gone wrong with this plan. In Juliet’s internal monolog, she says, “How if, when when i am laid into the tomb I wake up before that time that Romeo come to redeem me?” This quote shows that Juliet is worried about the possible consequences of taking the poison the Friar gave her. Both of them know that there are many things that could go wrong with this plan. Also in Juliet’ monologue she says, “What if it be a poison which the Friar Subtly hath ministered to have me dead, Lest is this marriage he should be dishonored Because he married me before to Romeo?” This quote shows that Juliet is doubting that Friar Lawrence did the right thing by marrying them and is wondering if the Friar would take action to cover up his mistake.

In conclusion, the deaths of Romeo and Juliet could have been avoided if Friar Lawrence had refused to marry them or if he had put a stop to their relationship after Romeo had been exiled. Both the Friar and Juliet had doubts about the safety of their relationship at times in the play. While Romeo and Juliet should have been expected to behave as adolescents, without fully developed judgement skills, Friar Lawrence was an adult and knew exactly what he was doing. Friar Lawrence should have been the responsible one in the situation and persuaded Romeo to forget Juliet the first time she was mentioned. This point illustrates the fact that peoples’ judgement can sometimes become clouded and that they make bad decisions in situations like the one shown in the play.

Wednesday, December 18, 2013

Where is the Power in Allegiant?

          Allegiant is the third book in the Divergent trilogy. the main characters are Tris and Tobias, two teenagers who formerly lived in a futuristic and isolated Chicago. They escaped from this corrupted, violent and warring city only to find that the rest of the world was just as corrupted and violent. It is ruled by people who oppress their enemies by discriminating against people with "damaged genes." These leaders think they have all the power.  Tris, Tobias, their friends from the city, and their new genetically damaged allies have more power than the leaders realize. Even though their numbers small, they can accomplish amazing things.

          The  government leaders in the outside world have a tight hold on their people. They keep control of the "damaged" people by keeping them poor. They control the people in cities like Tris' and Tobias's by watching through security cameras and in introducing drugs that cause memory loss and even death when things get out of hand. These cities were experiments trying to weed out the genetically pure people from the more common genetically damaged people . They also control the genetically pure people who have allied with the leaders and their causes by feeding them false or twisted information. If everyone access to all of the pure, true facts then people would be able to decide for themselves what they believed without someone influencing their decisions.

         Tris, Tobias, and their friends try to take some of the power away from these leaders. They use different elements to attack the system from within. Tris goes in as a spy, pretending to be interested in getting a job in the council and others attempt to use the memory erasing drug against everyone with prejudice twoards the genetically damage to people. They are able to use their determination, intelligence, and strength against the most powerful people they have ever encountered.

         The story starts out with these leaders holding all of the power but it is threatened to be taken away from them by Tris and Tobias. This book teaches that you don't need to be numerous or start out with power to make a change in the world. I don't agree with all of the methods used to dethrone the government and I hope that our country is never in the position of needing that kind of fixing. Another constant theme throughout the story is information - or lack of. It shows that information is power and that if you control the information you control the people. It is unjust to keep people misinformed and supporting a cause they don't understand.

Sunday, October 20, 2013

Reading Response- Upfront E-waste

          Upfront’s article, “Where Your Cellphone Goes to Die,” by Leyla Arcarglu, is about what happens to our electronics when we recycle them, or don’t. Young children and women in poor countries melt down our computers, cell phones, and TVs to extract small amounts of valuable metals. They breathe toxic fumes and deal with dangerous substances with their bare hands. These people should not be allowed to continue this work, at least in the form in which it currently exists. Electronics manufacturers need to step up to make changes to improve these workers’ lives.
         This work puts human health and even lives at risk. The author writes, “In India, young boys smash computer batteries with mallets to recover cadmium, covering their hands and feet with toxic flecks as they work.” The author also writes, “The World Health Organization reports that even a low level of lead, cadmium, and mercury – all of which can be found in old phones – can cause irreversible neurological damage and threaten the development of a child.” Yes, this work does help the environment – if we don’t recycle, chemicals leach from landfills and hurt soil and rivers through runoff, and we have to mine more of them in destructive ways - but there are better options than this for how to recycle our e-waste.
         Some solutions to this problem are for Congress to pass the Responsible Electronics Recycling Act and for electronics manufacturers to make disassembly safer. The article describes the goal of the RERA as, “The aim is to stop dumping e-waste on the world’s poorest nations and thus to provide an incentive for safer waste management in the U.S.” If this law was passed, then children and women in poor countries wouldn’t be exposed to dangerous materials anymore. Another solution mentioned in the text is “changes in the way manufacturers glue, screw, and solder components together would make it easier to dismantle discarded phones and thus reduce the risks posed by crude recycling technologies, like those employed by children in Ghana.”
         While these working conditions are terrible, the people working on electronic recycling in poor countries rely on these jobs to support themselves and their families. If these jobs were taken away, these boys would lose their jobs and might have no other work. Companies can still improve the conditions for these workers while keeping these jobs in place by making it easier to disassemble electronics. That way, they wouldn’t have to smash and burn them, thereby exposing themselves to dangerous materials. Electronic manufactures need to step up and take responsibility for the damaging ways their products are being recycled.
         When we recycle our out-of-date electronic products, we put them in a box and feel like we’re doing something good for the environment. But most people don’t fully understand what “recycling” is doing to workers in poor countries. We are not being informed about how dangerous these jobs are, and how these workers are being put at risk just so that we can buy the latest iPhone and not worry about the environmental damage from throwing away our old electronics. These issues are hidden from us so we don’t have to think about them – the manufactures want us to continue spending money on their new products. It’s time for the public to be informed about the risks and issues around recycling these products so that we can improve working conditions in the poor countries that are taking our e-waste. There’s no quick and easy solution – if we pass laws that prevent us from sending them, the workers will lose their livelihoods and we’ll likely just send the dangerous work somewhere else. Something that we can do is hold on to our old electronics for longer and not buy the latest gadget the second it comes out. Also, we need to demand that manufacturers make changes to their products that reduce the risks of recycling. 

Wednesday, October 2, 2013

Tell the Wolves I'm Home

Jane Zeman
Reading Response- Tell the Wolves I’m Home
          The novel, “Tell the Wolves I’m Home” by Carol Rifka Brunt, is about a girl named June and her life after her uncle, who is also her best friend, dies. A couple of days after the funeral she is contacted by her uncle Finn’s secret boyfriend. In the story, different people cope with this loss in different ways. The main characters are June, her mom, and Toby, Finn’s boyfriend.
          June deals with the loss of her uncle by pretending to be in a different time. When she first finds out that her uncle is dying June says, “I closed my eyes and tried to make the diner disappear.” She attempts to make the problems facing her disappear by imagining they’re not there. June also likes to walk through the woods with a scenario in mind, pretending to be anyone besides herself. The author writes, “I tried to keep my mind on the story I was telling myself, where I was the only one strong enough to hunt for my village…” She is unsatisfied with her life so she turns to other lives to escape hers.
          June’s mom deals with her brother’s death differently than June. When she first tells June about Finn she says, “‘Finn’s dying June.’ She could have said that Finn was sick- even really sick-but she didn’t. She told me straight out that Finn was dying. My mother wasn’t always like that. She wasn’t always one for harsh truths, but this time she must have figured that it meant less talking, less explaining.” This tells readers that June’s mom deals with her issues the least she can. If she doesn’t have to think about it, it’s not there. Also, when Greta, June’s sister, finds an article about Finn (he’s a famous artist) in the New York Times and tries to read it to the family, June’s mom says, “‘Okay Greta, enough now.’ My mother reached for the paper.” She doesn’t want to think about her brother’s death.
          Finn’s boyfriend, Toby, is also devastated when Finn dies and he deals with it by drinking and smoking but also by spending time with June.  In the text it says, “There were dirty plates and glasses everywhere, records lying around out of their sleeves, and at least three ashtrays overflowing with tea bags and cigarette butts.” Without Finn, Toby doesn’t take care of himself or the apartment. He needs June to help him through life without him. When June has a lot of homework and can’t go over to Toby’s, he says, ‘“I could help you. If you think that would work. Keep you company.’
 ‘I don’t know.’ (June says)  
‘Oh go on. I promise it’ll be better than sitting home on your own.’  I hadn’t expected Toby to offer to help.
‘You don’t have to do that. It’s okay.’  He sighed.
‘I want you to come.’” This conversation shows that Toby really relies on June. He is not an independent self-supporting adult.

          The story is mainly about how June copes with her best friend’s death and what she discovers about his life, after he is dead.  She is not the only one that has to deal with Finn's death. Her mom and Toby both have their ways of coping.  This book showed me that big issues such as death can sometimes draw people closer, but it can also push others away. Toby and June never would have met, if not for Finn dying, and they became very close because of it. However June's mom became more withdrawn and far from her family. June and Greta's relationship suffered from her spending so much time with Toby. Everyone in the book deals with death in different ways, some ways have benefits and some ways have negative effects.

Friday, September 27, 2013

Faithful Elephants

“Faithful Elephants” Reading Response
9/27/13

The story “Faithful Elephants” by Yukio Tsuchiya teaches that war causes many different kinds of tragedies. The story is about a zoo in Tokyo during World War II that is forced, by the government, to kill all the dangerous animals so that they couldn't escape and stampede the city if bombs dropped on the zoo. Three elephants, John, Tonky, and Wanly, need to be starved to death, as their skin is too thick for the poison syringe. this book shows that there are more consequences associated with war than just death. Death is one kind of tragedy portrayed in the story. In this story, animals are slowly and painfully killed, but many people die in wars as well. Another tragedy in the story is that the people that survive remember horrors that they have witnessed.

War causes people and animals to die cruel and tragic deaths. The author writes, “…all of the lions, tigers, leopards, bears, and big snakes were poisoned to death.” These innocent animals would have continued living if not for the war. In the story it also says, “…Tonky and Wanly were dead. Both died leaning against the bars of their cage with their trunks stretched high in the air….” Animals are not the only ones who die in war, soldiers and civilians also die. It is unfair that these people and animals have their lives taken away like this.

Death is just one of the tragedies caused by war. Another is that the people who survive have to live with the memories of death and destruction. The author writes, “Seeing his beloved elephants die this way, the elephant trainer felt as if his heart would break.” The trainer does not die, but he is greatly affected by the elephants’ death. The zookeepers protest, “Stop the war! Stop the war! Stop all wars!” They are all so heartbroken by the elephants’ deaths. Many civilians and soldiers that are killed have families that survive. Those survivors will always remember the tragedies of war.



In conclusion, this book shows that death is not the only consequence inflicted by war. “Faithful Elephants” portrays this by describing the zookeepers’ and trainer’s emotions, not just by explaining how the elephants died. This story was very touching for this reason. Readers can see right into the trainer’s heart and feel what he is feeling. This story shows the injustices of war. This is very important because there are places being bombed right now, and people being killed, soldiers and civilians alike. This story should be read so that we don’t repeat the past and cause more suffering.

Wednesday, September 18, 2013

RR-The Great Gatsby

Jane Zeman 811 9/18/13
Reading Response - The Great Gatsby

           The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald is about social class, love, and death. Nick Carraway, the narrator, is a middle-class man who lives in a small house on the West Egg of Long Island, N.Y. There is a mansion next to his house. The owner of that house is Jay Gatsby. At first, Carraway thinks that Gatsby is just another self-absorbed rich man, but he doesn’t really know anything about him. Towards the middle of the story as he grows closer to Gatsby, his history and true feelings start to become clear. By the end of the book Carraway knows all about him and sees him for what he really is.
At the beginning of the story, the narrator doesn’t know much about Gatsby, but assumes the worst. He narrates, “…Gatsby, who represented everything for which I have an unaffected scorn.” He means that he doesn’t respect Gatsby, because he is rich. He says, “‘Who is he?’ I demanded. ‘Do you know?’ ‘He’s just a man named Gatsby.’ [She said] ‘Where’s he from I mean? And what does he do?’” Gatsby is very mysterious and aloof. Also, Carraway first meets Gatsby at a party in which none of the guests have ever met him or know anything about him. Carraway starts off without knowing anything about the man who will soon be his close friend.
          About half way through the book Carraway’s primary assumptions are gone and he is starting to learn who Gatsby really is. His friend Jordan knows more about it than he does and tells him about why Gatsby bought a place on Long Island, “‘It was a strange coincidence,’ I said. ‘But it wasn’t a coincidence at all.’ [said Jordan] ‘Why not?’ ‘Gatsby bought that house so that Daisy would be just across the bay.’…He came alive to me, delivered suddenly from the womb of his purposeless splendor.” This means that before, Gatsby was meaningless in Carraway’s eyes, but now he sees that Gatsby was motivated by love to move to Long Island. Another example of him learning more about Gatsby is, “‘…I’ve been in several things,’ he corrected himself. ‘I was in the drug business and then I was in the oil business. But I’m not in either one now.’”Gatsby is telling him how he made his money. Carraway thought that he had inherited all his money, but that is not where it came from.
          In the end, Carraway is fully informed and understands why and how Gatsby did the things that he did. For example, “I don’t mean that he had traded on his phantom millions, but he had deliberately given Daisy a sense of security; he let her believe that he was a person from the same stratum as herself – that he was fully able to take care of her. As a matter of fact, he had no such facilities – he had no comfortable family standing behind him, and he was liable at the whim of an impersonal government to be blown anywhere about the world.” These are Carraway’s own ideas and beliefs about how Gatsby did what he did. Also the author writes, “He talked a lot about the past, and I gathered that he wanted to recover something, some idea of himself, perhaps, that had gone into loving Daisy. His life had been confused and disordered since then, but if he could once return to a certain starting place and go over it all slowly he could find out what the thing was…” Carrraway is very good at reading into Gatsby’s thoughts and emotions.

In conclusion, Gatsby started out kind of mysterious, but Carraway was able to figure him out by the end. The information about Gatsby slowly trickled in from various sources throughout the course of the story. Gatsby seemed to be shallow and egotistical, judging from his house and his parties, but he turned out to be much more interesting than that. He was able to convince and manipulate Daisy into thinking she was safe and used Carraway to get to Daisy, but in the end he still thought he was a good man.